Taylor Swift is Not One of the Greatest of All Time. Sorry
Summary
A stranger passionately defends Taylor Swift as "the Bob Dylan of young women," sparking a heated debate with Kareem about whether she belongs among the greatest lyricists of all time. She argues that Swift has uniquely chronicled the experience of growing up female, from age 12 to womanhood, and points to the prophetic line "your enemies will defeat themselves before you have a chance to swing" as evidence of her artistry. Kareem pushes back hard. He questions whether "Shake It Off" was a mistake and challenges the idea that Swift and Eminem can occupy the same category. The defender insists Swift's mainstream singles don't represent her true genius, which lives in the deep cuts of her discography, and that the media unfairly reduced her to just breakup songs.
Featured guests
Full Transcript
So, what's your take? Taylor Swift is one of the greatest lyricists of all time. 100% disagree.
What do you think about Eminem? Eminem is also great. They can't both be in the same category.
Give me a Taylor Swift lyric that's so wonderful. Your enemies will defeat themselves before you have a chance to swing. Sounds like something I would write in my notes out—no, absolutely not. It's, it's actually poetic and prophetic.
Wait, okay. I'm going to—because I respect women, I'm going to let you sound off. Okay, preach. I don't think there's ever been a musical artist who has accurately portrayed what it's like to grow up as a girl from the time she's 12 years old to becoming a woman. Taylor Swift is basically the Bob Dylan of young women.
Wow. W, wow. What about that song "Shake It Off"? Can you admit that it was a mistake thing? I think a lot of her singles that have been put out don't actually show the scope of her artistry. If you go deep cut in her discography, you will find that she is a musical genius and that there is a narrative that has been created by the media to say that she only writes songs about breakup.